Talking Loud and Saying Nothing

Embed from Getty Images

(Pictured: James Brown on stage, 1972.)

OK, let’s do that thing where after we listen to an American Top 40 show, we look at the Bottom 60 of the same week’s chart to see and hear what there. This is from March 25, 1972.

42. “Talking Loud and Saying Nothing (Part 1)”/James Brown
44. “King Heroin”/James Brown
James Brown put 15 singles on American Top 40 between 1970 and 1974, but it was his enormous popularity in the R&B market that got him there. The people buying “King Heroin” weren’t the same ones buying “Puppy Love” and “Horse With No Name,” but they were buying it in numbers sufficient to make it competitive.

45. “I Can’t Help Myself”/Donnie Elbert. Elbert hit the Hot 100 four times in two years, but “Where Did Our Love Go” and “I Can’t Help Myself” made #15 and #22 respectively. Each one takes the Motown groove of the 60s and updates it in a uniquely 70s way. They don’t improve on the originals because how could they, but they’re pretty good on their own.

47. “Tiny Dancer”/Elton John. Surely “Tiny Dancer” was a big hit, as it is one of Elton’s more familiar songs. But it was not, peaking at #29 in Cash Box and #41 in Billboard. It made local Top 10s in Honolulu, Miami/Fort Lauderdale, and some smaller markets. There are no ARSA listings for it from any station in New York, Chicago, or Los Angeles.

49. “Suavecito”/Malo. There is nothing about “Suavecito” that isn’t great, although I think it’s one of those cases where the single edit is superior to the long version. In either version, however, it sounds like the first bright, warm days of spring.

55. “Son of My Father”/Giorgio
91. “Son of My Father”/Chicory
That’s Giorgio Moroder, future pioneer of electronic and dance music, most famously with Donna Summer. His “Son of My Father” sounded unlike anything that had been on stateside Top 40 radio before. The Chicory version had been to #1 in the UK in February, about the time both versions first charted in the United States. Giorgio would get to #46 here, but Chicory (known as Chicory Tip in the UK before the tip was snipped for the American market) was done at #91.

58. “Iron Man”/Black Sabbath. What’s this doing here? It’s doing pretty well, actually. Down from a peak of #52 and in its ninth week on the Hot 100, “Iron Man” would go all the way to #1 at Seattle’s KSEA in San Diego in May, in a Top 10 that also featured “First Time Ever I Saw Your Face,” “Rockin’ Robin,” and Don McLean’s “Vincent.” It was #2 in San Diego, #4 in Louisville, and #8 in Minneapolis/St. Paul. But again, there’s no record of New York, Chicago, or Los Angeles Top 40 airplay at ARSA.

63. “Rock and Roll”/Led Zeppelin. “Black Dog” had been a #15 hit earlier in the year, and “Rock and Roll” seems more commercial, but it would stall out at #47. Its highest position at ARSA is #9 at WFRS, an AM station in Big Rapids, Michigan, which is up in the middle of nowhere but is also the home of Ferris State University, which might account for its wildly eclectic playlist.

78. “Baby Blue”/Badfinger
79. “The Family of Man”/Three Dog Night
Badfinger and Three Dog Night are debuts in this week, both great AM radio records that come out of the gate at full force and never let up. “Baby Blue” was remixed from the Straight Up album for American single release, and that’s the version you want. It punches you in the face, but in a good way.

82. “Nice to Be With You”/Gallery. This record will require 10 weeks just to crack the Top 40 but only four more to make the Top 10, finally peaking at #4 at the end of June. It’s one of the records that takes me most vividly back to the first days of that summer: school’s out and the swimming pool is in the dooryard, but for the first time, I am also expected to drive a tractor on the farm whether I want to or not. It’s my first experience with the world of work as it would be forever after.

A lot of books have been written about individual years in music, mainly from the 60s, and there’s a new one about 1984. But surely there’s material enough for a book about 1972: the ongoing crossfade between 60s and 70s styles, the rise of soft rock and prog rock, the underrated soul music of the time, and the historical forces that would, by 1974, transform the pop-music landscape into something entirely different. I’m not the person to write it, but I’d read it.

13 thoughts on “Talking Loud and Saying Nothing

  1. mikehagerty

    You had me at “Suavecito”.

    As for Elton in Los Angeles, KRLA and KHJ did play “Tiny Dancer”, but as an LP cut when the “Madman Across The Water” LP first came out in November of 1971—so by the time it was a single, both stations were done with it.

    1. mikehagerty

      Steve E: And “Rotten Peaches”. KHJ was into album cuts for part of ’71 and pretty close to all of ’72—a reaction to KLOS-FM, which leapt into the Top 5 in evenings in the fall of ’71 from 11th the year before (as KABC-FM)—and which beat KHJ in that timeslot (7-midnight) in the fall of ’72.

  2. Jim Cummings

    Let me be the first to say that you should write that book, but I don’t think that you should stop at 1972.
    Joey Molland released a CD of Badfinger covers today, with guest artists. It includes “Baby Blue”.
    PS: Great Sidepiece…

  3. Wesley

    “Iron Man” would go all the way to #1 at Seattle’s KSEA in May, in a Top 10 that also featured “First Time Ever I Saw Your Face,” “Rockin’ Robin,” and Don McLean’s “Vincent.”

    Now that’s one playlist would still bend my mind if I heard it on the radio late one night. Which again attests to what jb said about pop music in 1972.

    1. mikehagerty


      KSEA was actually San Diego, at 97.3 FM, from 1964-1975. It was trying to fit in a perceived gap between the then-freeform KPRI-FM and the more traditional Top 40s of KCBQ-AM and KGB-AM (which went quasi-progressive itself in April of ’72).

      “Iron Man” appears to have made #1 at KCBQ, as well.

      In L.A., neither KHJ nor KRLA appears to have touched it, and I don’t recall it on KKDJ, either.

      In San Francisco, it doesn’t seem KFRC played it when new, but it’s part of the legendary “Hummel Tape”, a composite of KFRC in the ’72-’73 time frame compiled by Production Director Ron Hummel, who includes Jack Friday doing a terrific layover of the beginning of “Iron Man” over the end of Edgar Winter’s “Frankenstein” (1973) while yelling “Incredible! Two monsters in a row at K-F-R-C!”

  4. spinetingler

    “Son of My Father” I know from 22 Explosive Hits, so I always assumed it was a bigger hit than that.

    NTBWY is one of the best songs/recordings of any era.

    1. porky

      I believe WLS played “Son…” quite a bit, I remember it fondly.

      Seems that those K-Tel records always featured Gallery in some way as well as lesser-known Stories and Five Man Electrical Band songs.

  5. mikehagerty

    Side note about “Nice To Be With You” from a Southern California perspective: KHJ didn’t play it.

    They DID play two of Gallery’s subsequent singles— “I Believe In Music”, which did much better in L.A. (#6) than it did nationally (#22) and “Big City Miss Ruth Ann”, which didn’t (#23 in Billboard, #24 at KHJ).

    But “Nice To Be With You” is one of the highest-charting singles nationally that KHJ simply ignored.

      1. SteveE

        mikehagerty: I always wondered what happened to “Nice to Be With You” on KHJ. It’s listed on the May 2, 1972, Boss 30 as a hitbound, so the station at least initially played it. But it didn’t advance from there.

  6. mikehagerty

    SteveE: Wow. You’re right. They did essentially the same thing a few weeks later with Sammy Davis Jr.’s “The Candy Man” (though it spent a week on the Thirty).

    Again, this was a moment when the biggest threat to them—especially at night—was KLOS, so I could see them ditching those records on image grounds—but then that leaves the songs they did still play.

    Also, it had to be a little sobering for KHJ., For a long time, they believed that you couldn’t have a Top 5 record in the USA without airplay on KHJ. Both Gallery and Sammy proved them wrong.

Leave a Reply to Wesley Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.