The Music to the Story in Your Eyes

Embed from Getty Images

(Pictured: Young Rod Stewart, performing with Faces in London on September 18, 1971.)

When I was a kid, I rode the school bus for over an hour every morning. If I go out and lose myself on those town roads now, I can find places that were on the route, but I have never been able to reconstruct the whole thing. Maybe that’s because I wasn’t really paying attention. That long morning bus ride is a critical part of my personal mythology, because in the fall of 1970, I started sitting under the radio speaker every morning, absorbing WLS like a sponge. By the time I got back on the bus in the fall of 1971, I knew that listening to the radio wasn’t going to be enough for me. I wanted to be on the radio.

American Top 40 recently repeated the show from September 18, 1971, and as I listened, I found myself looking out the window of the bus. That, and being fairly impressed by just a remarkable list of songs. It’s as close to all killer and no filler as any AT40 ever gets. It’s loaded with soul classics: “Thin Line Between Love and Hate,” “Mercy Mercy Me,” James Brown’s “Make It Funky,” Stevie Wonder’s “If You Really Love Me,” “Tired of Being Alone” by Al Green, plus “Whatcha See Is Whatcha Get,” “Ain’t No Sunshine,” and “Spanish Harlem.” Apart from those, the radio was rockin’ in that bygone late-summer week. Some notables are on the flip.

29. “Rain Dance”/Guess Who. Forty-four years later, “Rain Dance” remains opaque and disturbing. “And I’m still sittin’ with my next door neighbor sayin’ / ‘Where’d you get the gun, John?'”

28. “Riders on the Storm”/Doors. We’ve been hearing this in pristine digital stereo for many years now, but the best way to hear it is still off the vinyl 45. There’s something about the vinyl medium—and I have no idea what—that gives “Riders on the Storm” an ominous edge that’s missing from every CD version I’ve ever heard, including CD reproductions of the original 45 edit.

24. “The Story in Your Eyes”/Moody Blues. Ten million repetitions of “Nights in White Satin” have erased the fact that these guys could rock pretty hard when they wanted to.

23. “Bangla Desh”/George Harrison. Casey introduces this with a mention of Harrison’s recent hit, “My Sweet Lord,” which he describes as a “Jesus-rock hit.” (Not exactly, no.) Also includes a mention of Harrison’s recent refugee benefit concerts in New York, held about six weeks earlier.

18. “Signs”/Five Man Electrical Band. I bought “Signs” on a 45 that summer, and was disappointed when I got it home and found that most of the hard-rockin’ introduction had been snipped from it. I didn’t lay hands on the long version until the CD era. If I say this is the greatest hit ever driven by a fuzztone guitar, somebody will inevitably think of a better one, so have at it.

17. “Liar”/Three Dog Night. Casey says that Three Dog Night picks their songs by a vote among the seven band members, and it takes six votes for a song to pass. “Mama Told Me Not to Come” was shot down twice before gaining acceptance, so the system worked, albeit slowly.

16. “Do You Know What I Mean”/Lee Michaels. There has never been anything else that sounded like this, not counting the rest of the Lee Michaels catalog.

15. “Won’t Get Fooled Again”/The Who. I bought this on a 45 that fall, and although the edits are jarring if you know the original well, it compacts the anger nicely.

7. “I Just Want to Celebrate”/Rare Earth. Another one with some significant differences between the 45 and the album. Both rock the hell out, though.

5. “Uncle Albert-Admiral Halsey”/Paul and Linda McCartney. Another 45 I bought, with as much Beatlesque whimsy as Paul would ever manage as a solo act.

4. “Maggie May”/Rod Stewart. Me, 2011: “‘Maggie May'” performs, for those of us who love it, the function great art is supposed to perform: It tells us who we are. And who we’ve been. And now that we’re 40 years older, who we’re going to be.”

This chart, as strong as it is, is topped by the weakest and most forgettable record of all: “Go Away Little Girl” by Donny Osmond, returning for a second week at the top. And despite all the great songs jockeying for position behind it, it would be #1 again the next week.

It was the 70s. We couldn’t help ourselves.

8 thoughts on “The Music to the Story in Your Eyes

  1. “If I say this is the greatest hit ever driven by a fuzztone guitar, somebody will inevitably think of a better one, so have at it.”
    “No Time,” the Guess Who.

    Speaking of whom, I love your shout-out to “Rain Dance,” a great and unjustly forgotten tune.
    Love the driving pulse.
    And the guitar solos, which sound different enough in tone and style to suggest that the band’s two guitarists are taking turns. (As a guitar geek, I get off on things like that.)
    Oh, yeah, and the words.
    “Can your telescope tell me where the sun’s gone?”

  2. “Goodbyes and Butterflys” (the album from which “Signs” comes) is top to bottom excellent.
    It was also my first introduction to that great, er, intro, having only been familiar with the single version from the radio. I bought the LP for 76 cents (at a Bicentennial sale, natch) while visiting my grandparents in tiny Preston County WV in the summer of ’76. It sounded awesome on their Silvertone console stereo.

    1. porkyxi

      .I second the awesome intro.. Those drums, as Sonny and Cher sang,”_ pounding a rhythm to the brain …” … actually I have never heard the doing without the pounding from into.. My station always played it, also the oldies station I now listen to..

    2. mackdaddyg

      I second these remarks about “Goodbyes and Butterflies.” I purchased that album almost 30 years ago, and it still remains a favorite from beginning to end. It needs a cd release.

      Also, this is the place where I first heard the long version of “Signs.” Blew my teenaged mind.

  3. Steve E.

    I was just starting eighth grade and into my fourth year of listening to KHJ and buying singles. “Maggie May” is a song that should long ago have suffered from overplay to my ears, and yet if anything it sounds even greater 44 years later. My God, Rod was so great back then. “Every Picture Tells a Story” was one of the few non-Beatles-related albums I bought back then. I agree about the edits on “Won’t Get Fooled Again,” but they do the job. (“Miracles” by Jefferson Starship might be my candidate for the smoothest editing of a long album track for a single. There are SO many edits in that single version, and yet I would swear they recorded it that way. It’s only when I hear the album track that I realize that the pieces of the single are all there.) Oh, and I love “Rain Dance” too, mystery and all. KHJ charted “Bangla Desh” for just two weeks and then it was gone.

  4. porky

    Another candidate for fuzz-driven song, the Guess Who scores again with “American Woman” (the first 45 I remember buying with my own money).

    These tunes remind me of a vacation we took; our newly divorced mom decided to take four kids west, CAMPING, no less. When I hear “Liar” I’m in a tent, staring up as the wind blows through the pine trees, wondering what lies ahead when we pack up the tents and head farther west. Oh, the power of music.

    1. See, I knew you guys would come up with better fuzztone songs. Clearly Canada was a leading exporter of that sound.

      Oddly enough, “Liar” calls up one of my few camping memories. Late that summer my cousin and I put up a tent in his backyard and we were permitted to sleep out there one night. (We were not permitted to build the bonfire we had been planning on, however.) I kept the radio on all night, and “Liar” is one of the songs that played over and over.

  5. Pingback: All Day Music | The Hits Just Keep On Comin'

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.