More Noodling With Jazz

With the decline of soul music in the 70s, those scattered soul-jazz 45s we discussed a while back disappeared from the radio too (except when they were taking us up to news time). There was still some jazz on Top 40 radio in the 1970s, but the nature of it changed.

Thirty-nine years ago this month, Deodato’s funk/fusion version of “Also Sprach Zarathustra (2001)” began its climb to an eventual spot in the top 10. (I have always been a big fan of it—its electric piano sound helps define 70s cool, and you just don’t hear that anymore.) Jazz fusion made inroads among rock fans who enjoyed the complexity of it—as we’ve mentioned here before, it’s not a particularly daunting leap from prog rock to fusion. But fusion was never going to be a singles medium.  Apart from “2001,” Weather Report’s “Birdland” came the closest. In 1985, fusion veteran Jan Hammer would score a #1 hit with “Miami Vice Theme,” but it’s not remotely jazz.

In the mid 1970s, Barry White’s Love Unlimited Orchestra gave a few jazz players the chance to collect a paycheck (including a young sax man named Kenny Gorelick, about whom we’ll have more to say below), but his soloists didn’t improvise, and the feel of the music was always more R&B than jazz.  Guitarist George Benson, who’d been making jazz records throughout the 1960s, had to become a singer before his commercial breakthrough with Breezin’ (1976). (That album’s instrumental title song did make the Top 40, however.) Thanks to “Feels So Good” (1978) and “Give It All You Got” (1980), veteran horn player Chuck Mangione was the biggest jazz crossover star of both the 70s and 80s, at least until Kenny G came along.

After his time with the Love Unlimited Orchestra, Kenny G first got noticed with the Jeff Lorber Fusion around the turn of the 1980s. He made three solo albums before the fourth, Duotones (1986), made him a star, thanks to the #4 single “Songbird.” And ever since, if the average person on the street can name a contemporary jazz player at all—which is doubtful—it’s likely they’ll come up with Kenny G pretty quickly. Every time he releases a record, it speeds to the top of the contemporary jazz charts.

But Kenny G’s detractors (and they are many) will tell you that because he doesn’t improvise much, and because he sticks to sweet, lyrical, utterly conventional melodies, he’s not a jazz player anymore. Pat Metheny is one of the most famous G-detractors, inspired to fabulous rhetorical heights by the decision to dub what he called Kenny G’s “lame-ass, jive, pseudo bluesy, out-of-tune, noodling, wimped out, fucked up playing” over the top of Louis Armstrong’s “What a Wonderful World” in 1999.

I remember playing “Songbird,” and another significant instrumental hit, “Silhouette,” on the radio in the late 80s, both of which struck me as inoffensive. But the more Kenny G I heard, the more I found myself annoyed by his tone on the soprano saxophone, which reminds me of this.

With radio formats and record charts so atomized these days, it’s hard to imagine anything remotely like jazz making anything remotely like a broad-based impact on the listening public, as “Songbird” and “Feels So Good” did a generation ago. If there are records or artists I’ve missed discussing here, I trust you’ll let me know.

3 thoughts on “More Noodling With Jazz

  1. Since you discussed mostly instrumentalists here, I assume you mean it’s hard to imagine anything remotely like *instrumental* jazz making a big impact.
    I think there’s always an opening for a torchy or bluesy jazz singer with just enough pop in their sound to break through.
    (Wasn’t Billy Paul mostly a jazz singer before and after “Me and Mrs. Jones”? Or am I making that up?)

    “Cantaloop” comes to mind as a popular song with jazz roots, shot through with something more modern to make it accessible. Though that one might have been more popular as background/bumper music than it actually was as a single — I associate it with going into and out of commercial breaks.

    I dunno — the neat thing about popular music is it surprises us from time to time. While I do not see instrumental jazz crossing over any time soon, that just means that someone nobody expected (some charismatic young trumpeter, maybe?) will come along and hit us where we don’t expect it.
    As Fats Waller put it, “One never knows, do one?”

    1. Something like “Cantaloop” is probably the closest thing to jazz we’re likely to hear in this world, although on further review it occurs to me that Norah Jones had a bit of jazz in her, too. My point is that I do not expect a performer whose first or main gig was jazz to become a pop superstar, a la Kenny G, anytime soon. But yeah, one never knows.

  2. I think at one time Al Hirt was categorized as a “jazz” artist. (Prolly because he played New Orleans a lot.) He always said he was NOT a jazz player. Brings to mind an old musician’s joke from 1970. “Who threw that brick at Al Hirt in the Mardi Gras parade? I dunno; either a commie bastard, or a music lover…..”

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.